Much more than an 'AIDS novel' as the blurb on the back unfortunately put it. Separate rooms felt like quiet Rilkean mediation on some of life's major themes.
1
3.8 stars really for minor imperfections in the whole 'detective' plot but it's still a dazzling novel for readers written by a passionate reader. I liked the French Lieutenant's Woman better (even though on the whole it's a less polished novel).
1
Slowly builds to a series of climaxes of varying intensity (i.e. each strand of thought gets to come into its own at various points in the novel: Marxism, Darwinism, crypto-feminist existentialism). A near-masterpiece undone only by its awkward amalgam of neo-Victorian postmodernism and standard existentialist modernism.
1
Stoner managed to sustain deep, quiet intensity that quickly elevated it from a merely good book to one of the good ones. Starts out as a realistic academic horror story and ends as a specimen of the best of realist fiction.
1
3 3/4 stars for the story with an extra 1/4 of a star for the concept in spite of how gimmicky it felt.
Merely adequate stylistically but worth reading as a cautionary tale. Highlights the important distinction between being general nice and a genuinely good person.
At its best, an homage to dystopian classics that came before; at its worst, well-written, really readable twaddle.
Finally finished it and as always my love for Virginia Woolf's nearly perfect prose (motivated by something other than merely for the sake of perfection) is even more deeply entrenched.
1
The audiobook's better but the essayistic format is really best expressed through Mindy Kaling's conversational tone.
This book did not age well. The rampant racism and sexism that are a sign of the times Maugham lived in make this Künstlerroman unbearable in several places. Plus for a fairly short book, there's a surprising amount of filler.
meh.
Didn't quite care for the last 3 but Jhumpa Lahiri's prose remains stolid in this collection (in a simultaneously reliably impressive yet also predictable fashion)
I feel I would've enjoyed reading a book simply about Emma more. The (inexplicable) relationship with Dexter is the novel's only real weak point and sadly its only one as well.